OA_show('Leaderboard - Xx90');
Choose your edition:

Search form

UPDATE: Gay Toronto man deported to Panama


UPDATE: Gay Toronto man deported to Panama

Israel Sanchez fled to Canada in 1988. He has lived in Toronto ever since. IMAGE 1 OF 1
Israel Sanchez had lived in Canada for 25 years
UPDATE: Feb 27 -- Israel Sanchez is back in Panama, after spending more than a month in a Canadian detention centre which he calls "a jail; plain and simple."

In a letter to Xtra, Sanchez says he spent his time in the West End Canadian Border Services detention facility surrounded by "murderers, rapists and commoncriminals." Two of whom tested positive for tuberculosis, he says.

Sanchez, who did not disclose his HIV-positive status while at the facility, feared for his health. Sanchez didn't even admit he was gay during his seven-week stay, fearing retribution from the other prisoners who were waiting to be deported.

"I really don't have a clue as to how get access to HIV medication here," says Sanchez of Panama, where he has not lived in 25 years.

While he might be out of the country, Sanchez and his lawyer continue their application to get Sanchez permanent residency here in Canada.

UPDATE: Feb 23 --
 Government to deport gay Torontonian Monday

After one last-ditch effort to stay Israel Sanchez's deportation, the Toronto resident is still set to be deported on Monday, Feb 25.

John Norquay, his lawyer, filed to defer the deportation until a judge can rule on whether or not Sanchez has grounds to stay in Canada under humanitarian and compassionate grounds.

While Sanchez will not be allowed to stay in Canada while that application is processed, it will continue if he is deported back to Panama. If a judge rules that he has sufficient ties to Canada and that there is some risk for him at home, he could be allowed to return and live here indefinitely.

Feb 22 -- Government to deport gay Torontonian

Israel Sanchez fled Panama in 1988, when he was only 21. A journalism student, Sanchez saw many of his colleagues "disappear" at the hands of dictator Manuel Noriega.
So Sanchez escaped, arriving in Toronto to take advantage of Canada's generous refugee system. But as his claim was being processed, a wrench was thrown into the machine – George HW Bush invaded Panama and installed a civilian government.
The Canadian Immigration and Refugee Board decided that the threat had passed and that Sanchez had no grounds to become a refugee. Having already established himself in Canada, he launched an appeal. In 1995, his appeal was dismissed – after having cycled through several lawyers, one of whom had a nervous breakdown.
Sanchez says he never heard from the immigration system after that. According to the system, he missed a pre-removal interview, and a deportation order was filed. Sanchez, seemingly oblivious, went on with his life. So when officers from the Canada Border Service Agency (CBSA) showed up on his doorstep Jan 8, he was surprised.
Over 25 years in Canada, Sanchez hardly made himself hard to find. Active in the queer and HIV communities, he made his living for more than a decade working as a bartender in the upscale Arcadian Court on Bay Street.
He got married in 2009, and his husband sponsored his residency status, finally giving him legal status in the country.
A year later, Sanchez and his husband opened up the trendy WAYLA bar in Leslieville. With a solid establishment in the city, they went to fill out the paperwork to get Sanchez's permanent residency status.
During his application, he says, he never heard one word about the outstanding deportation order – one that's been on the books for more than a decade.
But things unravelled. Sanchez and his husband split acrimoniously. Divorce proceedings are ongoing to see who will take over the bar. Sanchez's sponsorship was revoked.
And then the border officers came. He was taken to the Toronto West Detention Centre and told that he would be sent back to Panama on Feb 25.
With the deportation order looming, he reached out to friends. They put him in touch with Michael Erickson, who published a petition in hopes of encouraging Immigration Minister Jason Kenney to intervene.
"People are in awe. It's shocking that someone who's been here for 25 years can just be grabbed and deported," Erickson says. "He's not been hiding. He's a business owner."
Citizenship and Immigration personnel point out that Sanchez has been in Canada illegally since 1998. The deportation order, no matter how old it is, still stands.
"Usually people know when something like this happens," Erickson says. But with the deportation coming out of left field, Sanchez was hardly ready to mount a legal case. He initially went through two lawyers – both were unreliable and didn't show up – before representing himself. He finally found proper legal representation from the HIV & AIDS Legal Clinic Ontario (HALCO).
John Norquay, a staff lawyer with HALCO, was assigned to Sanchez's case and says the whole thing is peculiar. He can't point to any other cases where the CBSA has taken more than a decade to enforce a deportation order – especially when the person hasn't been hiding.
Norquay figures that Sanchez just "crossed his fingers and hoped for the best" after he didn't hear back from the immigration system in 1995.
"It sounds to me that they just got around to figuring out where he was," Norquay says. CBSA told Norquay that it was all a lack of interdepartmental communication by the CBSA and Immigration Canada, yet Norquay says he frequently deals with cases where Immigration passes on the location of those with outstanding deportation orders.

A spokesperson for Citizenship and Immigration says that they, and the CBSA, make every effort to inform applicants about hearing dates and deportation orders, adding that it is the claimants' responsibility to ensure that the government has their correct contact information. 
While Sanchez could be sent back to Panama – a country he hasn't lived in since he was 21 – on Monday afternoon, Norquay sees a sliver of hope. In August, Sanchez filed an application to stay in Canada on humanitarian and compassionate grounds. If he can convince a Citizenship and Immigration judge that he is adequately settled in Canada and that Panama isn't a good place for him (Norquay points out that "Panama is not a great place for gays . . . [nor] HIV-positive people"), he might just be allowed to return to Canada. Norquay is hoping to get that request heard before the deportation on Monday.
Norquay says public support could play an important role in proving that Sanchez really is an established community member in Toronto. 

Xtra is following this story. 
OA_show('Text Ad - #1');
OA_show('Text Ad - #2');


Nothing seems right about this...
Mike from Winnipeg, thank you for reminding me what a bigot sounds like, and yes Sam there is a great deal of inequity in this situation. It is a political action and an action which defies logic. What conservative government acts in good faith? If the man were not gay and had a wife, even a divorced wife and maybe a kid or two running around somewhere. I am sure the outcome would have been quite different.
Age... an issue
@ Trevor, Toronto.

It truly is interesting how the two cases, both Central American were dealth with differently . Ironcially, the one who got to stay in Canada was the young 25 year old and the one who got botted was the one had lived in Canada for 25 years! Even thought its not the bad, as I found out that Panama where the guy was returned to, does have a governmental sponsored HIV medication programme, which probably one of the Reasons why his HIV poz status was not a factor in stopping his deportation on humanitarian grounds.

MORAL of the story: Even in the straight world, younger gay men get treated better than older gays.
He broke the law
Yes, there are holes in the system and some will get away and others will not. BUT in this particular case we have a man who defied immigration officials and a deportation order and thus was here illegally. It may have taken a while but now its time for Sanchez to pay for his deliberate act of contempt for Canada and it's laws. The past will catch up to everyone at some point. This man does not deserve the support of Canadians. We might all be a gay ''community'' but we are Canadians first. Sanchez is not and he never made any attempt to become one properly.
Comparing two recent cases
It's interesting to compare and contrast two recent cases of gay men from Central America who sought to avoid deportation after being in Canada illegally for a number of years. Israel Sanchez (originally from Panama) was deported after entering Canada illegally and ignoring unfavourable decisions by Canadian immigration authorities. In contrast, Alvaro Orozco (originally from Nicaragua), was allowed to stay in Canada on humanitarian grounds even though he was previously found not be a true refugee and went underground after receiving unfavourable decisions by Canadian immigration authorities. See http://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/toronto/story/2011/06/02/toronto-artist-deportation578.html Both cases show that illegal immigrants in Canada are able to avoid detection or enforcement actions by Canadian immigration authorities for several years. Both cases allow Immigration Minister Jason Kenney to say that pre-deportation appeals on humanitarian or other grounds are considered on a case-by-case basis and that homophobia was not at play: Orozco's case was found to be deserving, while Sanchez's case was not. It's also interesting that Orozco received far more visible support from Toronto LGBT activists and the Toronto LGBT community than Sanchez. Both cases also suggest that the lawyers initially retained by Orozco and Sanchez may not have been competent or may not have been doing their best for their client.
What else would you expect?
This is Canada folks. The place with fake human rights. As long as people continue to frolic to the polling stations and award the Harpers of this country a majority, there will be no human rights. Didn't you learn anything from the G20 fiasco in Toronto? Look the guy is gay. In spite of the pure logic ie been in Canada forever, paid taxes blah blah blah...under the current conditions in this country, he didn't stand a chance. Kennedy is clearly sending out a warning to queer folk. As for support from the community. What community? You mean all these babbling queers with cell phone shoved up their wazzu's? Who are so deliriously fabulous they bash into each other as they text themselves to no where? Don't look for it there, cus it don't exist. This guy's only hope is a hetro immigration lawyer who not only doesn't give a crap if Sanchez is cute or not, but has the balls to take this as far as it can go. In the mean time I would be concerned about how he is going to get his hands on the meds he needs. Justin,any suggestions? Or are you done with this?
the comments by the queers of Canada are rather revealing...that a gay man who is HIV positive is being deported to a place which he hasn't been in for almost 25 years and wouldn't have access to for life saving medication;

I know I had something similar as a south Asian when I got elected to a local Aids Committee and the gays went crazy until I was forced to resign...

Some people never change, do they...
The issue is omissions, not errors
Clearly, Justin, what people are reacting to here is omissions in your story, not outright errors.
If you think there's an error in the story, feel free to reach me at justinrling@gmail.com

I do this for a living. I know all about due diligence.
Do your research
I agree with Isabelle...
Check the facts
I fear a well-intentioned rush to activism is trumping the checking of facts in this story. Xtra, I would urge you to do some due diligence on the story before engaging your publication and your readers any further in taking action on this matter.


Sign in or Register to post comments